Archived Analysis

A snapshot of Premodern from September 16, 2025.

Premodern: Participation trending downwards needs addressing.
Analysis from September 16, 2025

The Premodern format sits at a Final Health Index of 62.6, suggesting a need for careful observation and possible adjustments. While not dire, this score indicates underlying issues that should be addressed to ensure the format's continued vibrancy.

The high Metagame Diversity Score of 83.3 and the Archetype Distribution Score of 95.5 are positives, indicating a healthy range of viable strategies. However, the low Event Growth Score (40.3) and Player Growth Score (27.4) are concerning, showing a clear downward trend in participation. The format needs an injection of new players and more organized play to thrive long-term. The historical data shows participation trending downward in the last few years.

Looking at the top decks, Goblins leads the pack at 8.6%, followed by Sligh (RDW) at 6%. Mono Black Aggro, Madness, White Weenie, and Elves are clustered at 3% each. Machine Head, Deadguy Ale, RG Aggro, and Terrageddon make up the rest of the Top 10, suggesting a metagame dominated by aggro strategies, which is also shown in the super-archetype breakdown. This top 10 provides a starting point for understanding the decks you should be prepared to face.

Based on Reddit discussions, there is a focus on whether any specific decks are becoming too prevalent. Cards like Force of Will and Wasteland remain points of contention. The community is actively exploring innovative takes on existing archetypes, like Stasis variations, and is on the lookout for underutilized cards. While the lack of a recent B&R announcement means no direct impact from that area, the format's health hinges on addressing the declining growth trends and fostering a welcoming environment for new players.

Back to Archive Index

Archived on: 9/16/2025, 12:21:15 AM

    Premodern: Participation trending downwards needs addressing. | MtG Health Index Archive