Archived Analysis

Vintage is in a holding pattern this week, with the Final Health Index landing at a middling 48.5. This suggests some areas for improvement, but not a complete crisis. Are we waiting for a shakeup? Let’s dive into the data.

The Metagame Diversity Score is a low 40.4, indicating a less varied format than we’d like. On the flip side, the Archetype Distribution Score is a high 93.3, meaning that existing archetypes are well-defined and represented. Event Growth is a flat 0.0, but Player Growth sits at 35.0, suggesting some player retention despite the challenges. The B&R Health Score is 65.0, perhaps reflecting the recent decision to hold off on changes and see how the format adapts.

Looking at the Top 10, Hatebear dominates at 14%, followed by MUD at 12%. Esper Control and Dimir Control each have a showing with 9% and 8% respectively. BUG Midrange is in the mix at 3%, and Azorius Aggro is at 2%, alongside Bazaar Aggro trailing at 1%. Jeskai Xerox is barely hanging on at 0.6%, with Goblins at a dismal 0.1% and other Aggro strategies at 0.3%. Overall, Aggro clocks in at 33%, Control at 22.2%, and Combo a significant 44.8%.

The Vintage community is buzzing about Doomsday strategies and whether they might need a look from the RC. The community also discusses White Plume Adventurer strategies, leveraging the Initiative mechanic. Orcish Bowmasters also continues to draw conversation. The lack of B&R changes indicates a desire to let the format breathe and see how it evolves.