Archived Analysis

Vintage is in a bit of a holding pattern, with the community debating the power level of Initiative decks while waiting to see if new strategies can break through. The format feels somewhat stagnant, caught between established powerhouses and brewing innovation.

The overall health index sits at 55.9, with a worrying Metagame Diversity Score of only 39.9. This confirms the feeling that things are a bit stale. Archetype Distribution is solid at 93.2, meaning the broad strokes are balanced, but the details are lacking variety. Player and Event growth are both down, painting a concerning picture for the long-term health of Vintage. The B&R Health Score is average, reflecting the "wait and see" approach.

Right now, Hatebears and MUD dominate, taking up a huge chunk of the metagame at 14% and 12% respectively. Dimir Control and Esper Control are also holding their own, showing control's continued presence. Combo still makes up 45% of the meta, compared to aggro's 33% and control's 22%, a marked increase compared to its historical average of 34.6%.

The Reddit community is buzzing about Initiative decks and whether or not they should be hit with the banhammer. Players are also experimenting with graveyard strategies and cards like 'Breach the Multiverse' to shake things up. Orcish Bowmasters remains a key player, while discussions about potential restrictions are ongoing. The sentiment is mixed, with some concerned about diversity and others optimistic about the potential for innovation. The lack of recent B&R changes regarding Lurrus indicates a hands-off approach for now, putting the pressure on players to adapt and innovate.